Expression of Concern Policy

The International Journal of New Trends in Arts, Sports & Science Education (IJTASE) is committed to upholding the highest standards of publication ethics and follows the Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE) guidelines. To ensure the transparency, integrity, and reliability of the published academic record, IJTASE may issue a formal Expression of Concern when credible evidence of potential research or publication misconduct—or serious doubts regarding the reliability of a published article—arises, but an investigation is inconclusive or prolonged.

Grounds for Issuing an Expression of Concern
An article may be subject to an Expression of Concern under any of the following circumstances:

Inconclusive Evidence of Misconduct: There is credible, substantiated evidence of potential research or publication misconduct (such as data fabrication, falsification, plagiarism, or duplicate publication), but conclusive proof is not yet available.

Ongoing Institutional or Editorial Investigation: Well-founded concerns have been raised regarding the validity or ethical compliance of a published article, and an investigation by the authors' affiliated institutions, external bodies, or the Editorial Board is still underway.

Prolonged or Delayed Investigation: An institutional or editorial inquiry into potential ethical breaches or major errors is prolonged, delayed, or unable to reach a timely resolution.

Lack of Cooperation: Authors or relevant institutions fail to respond to or cooperate with an active editorial inquiry within a reasonable timeframe.

Expression of Concern Procedure and Notices

Investigation: When credible concerns are brought to the editorial office, IJTASE initiates a preliminary assessment in accordance with COPE flowcharts. Authors are notified and given an opportunity to respond, and the matter may be referred to the authors' affiliated institutions for formal investigation.

Publication of Notice: If interim action is warranted to alert readers while an investigation proceeds, a formal Expression of Concern Notice is published as soon as possible. The notice clearly identifies the article in question (title and authors), states the specific reasons for the concern without prejudging the outcome, and avoids defamatory or unsubstantiated statements.

Accessibility and Archiving: Expression of Concern notices are freely accessible to all readers (no paywall) and are permanently and bidirectionally linked to the original article via permanent URLs and article metadata on the journal's website. The original version of record remains preserved in the journal's archive while the notice stays active.

Post-Investigation Resolution: Once the investigation concludes and definitive evidence is obtained, IJTASE promptly updates the scholarly record by linking a subsequent formal notice to both the original article and the Expression of Concern—either retracting the article (under the Retraction Policy), issuing a correction (under the Correction Policy), or publishing a formal resolution notice if the concerns are found to be unsubstantiated.

Note: Minor errors that do not affect the overall validity or conclusions of an article are addressed directly through a formal Correction (Erratum/Corrigendum), whereas confirmed major misconduct or invalidating errors are addressed through a formal Retraction.